logo
New Delhi

Tata Punch vs Mahindra Scorpio Comparison

Compare Tata Punch vs Mahindra Scorpio to know which is better. Detailed cars comparison on Tata Punch vs Mahindra Scorpio compare price, specs, mileage, performance, reviews and other features on car&bike.

Punch vs Scorpio Comparison Overview

Key HighlightsPunchScorpio
Price5.5 L3.33 L
Power1199 CC2179 CC
ClassSUVSUV
Mileage19 - 20 KM/L15 KM/L
Punch
Tata Punch
*Ex-Showroom Price
₹5.5 L
Scorpio
Mahindra Scorpio
*Ex-Showroom Price
₹3.33 L
+
Add
Only Show Differences
Pure
Tata Punch
Pure
5.5 L
Xtreme
Mahindra Scorpio
Xtreme
3.33 L
OverviewSpecificationFeatures

Overview

EMI Starting From₹10,275/month₹6,207/month
User Rating
8.7
7.3
Value For Money8.758.00
Significance8.758.00
Styling9.506.75
Comfort8.007.25
Safety9.007.00
Environment7.756.00
Merit Or Usp8.508.00

Specifications

Engine Type1.2-litre RevotronN/A
Displacement (CC)1199 CCN/A
No. of Cylinders3N/A
Power85 bhp @ 6000 rpmN/A
Torque113 Nm @ 3200-3400 rpmN/A
Top Speed150N/A
Acceleration 0 to 100 Kmph16.5N/A
No. of gears5N/A
Drive TrainFWDN/A
Turbocharger NoN/A
Emissions StandardBS VI 2.0N/A

Features

Air ConditionerManual-
Front ACSingle Zone, Common Fan Speed Control-
Rear AC No-
Third Row AC Zone No-
Heater Yes-
Climate Control Yes-
Paddle Shift No-
Idle Start/Stop Button No-
Cruise Control Yes-
Power Windows Yes-
Keyless Entry Yes-
Push Start Stop Button Yes-
Remote Engine Start No-
Hands-Free Tailgate No-
Steering Mounted Audio Yes-
Cooled Glovebox No-
Rain Sensing Wipers No-
Automatic Headlamps No-
Electric Tailgate No-
Adjustable ORVMs No-
Power Outlets 12V Yes-
Wireless Phone Charger No-
Central Remote Locking With Flip Key No-
Follow-me-home headlamps No-
One-touch-down Door Window No-
Projector Headlamps No-

Pros Cons of Tata Punch

Pros

  • Tata Punch is built on the ALFA platform, making it a robust and compact micro SUV with excellent ground clearance of 187 mm, perfect for rough terrains and urban roads alike.
  • The 1.2-litre Revotron petrol engine delivers 85 bhp and 113 Nm of torque, providing peppy performance for city commutes, especially with the light and easy-to-drive nature of the 5-speed manual and AMT versions.
  • It has scored a 5-star safety rating from Global NCAP, making it one of the safest vehicles in its segment, with dual airbags, ABS with EBD, and ISOFIX child seat anchors as standard.

Cons

  • The AMT gearbox shows hesitation during gear shifts, particularly from first to third, which can affect the smoothness of the drive.
  • The rear seat comfort is compromised due to limited legroom, and while it's a compact SUV, the back row can feel tight for taller passengers.
  • The infotainment screen is relatively small at 7 inches and could be more responsive, with noticeable lag during operation

Verdict

Tata Punch is a strong contender in the micro SUV segment, offering a blend of SUV styling, solid safety credentials, and practical features at an affordable price point. While there are minor issues with the AMT gearbox and rear seat space, the overall value for money, robust build quality, and top-tier safety make it a great choice for urban families looking for a compact, safe, and stylish vehicle.

Pros Cons of Mahindra Scorpio

Pros

  • Big on muscle and also legacy
  • The Scorpio gets a very refined diesel mHawk engine
  • The Scorpio is rugged and macho in terms of looks

Cons

  • The engine is a little noisy
  • The automatic transmission is a little sluggish
  • The Scorpio does not get many features

Verdict

The Mahindra Scorpio retains its iconic identity while presenting itself as more than just a familiar favorite in a revamped package. Considerable effort has been invested in its development, and the results are prominently visible. The vehicle exhibits significant enhancements over its predecessor, showcasing fine-tuning and improved overall performance. While there's always room for further aesthetic and driving experience enhancements, it's commendable that the Scorpio transcends beyond being a mere facelift. It genuinely represents a new generation, offering a fresh and evolved driving experience while staying true to the robust essence that has defined the Scorpio legacy.

Explore Cars Similar to Tata Punch

Explore Cars Similar to Mahindra Scorpio

Popular New Car Comparison

Compare Cars By Body Type

Recent Popular Car Comparison In India

Latest Comparison Video

Read More on "Tata Punch" vs "Mahindra Scorpio"