Manual vs Automatic Transmission: Pros & Cons
By Carandbike Team
2 mins read
Published on August 25, 2022
- Manual transmission is still the preferred option in India
- Automatics are a boon in heavy traffic situations
- The sales of automatic cars is catching up
one of the very first questions that most likely pops into everyone's mind when they decide to buy a new car is whether to go for an automatic or manual transmission. It's a good question to ask, considering that both transmission types have their own pros and cons. And both also have their own set of loyalists who will always try to sway you in their preferred direction. But it's better to know the facts yourself before making your own choice. That's why we decided to list out the pros and cons of automatic and manual transmissions by elaborating on the various aspects of driving that they influence.
Pros of automatic transmission cars
- Easier to learn: Automatic transmission cars do not feature a clutch and hence require only one foot of yours to be active for switching between the brake and the accelerator. Their gear-changing mechanism is also very uncomplicated.
- Better safety: Since the left hand of the driver is almost always free, they can rest it on the steering wheel, giving them more control over the car. And with no gears to change, again and again, they can concentrate more on the road ahead of them instead of the clutch and the stick shift.
- Best for heavy traffic: The constant stress of switching gears by repeatedly hitting the clutch is hell for drivers. That's why automatic cars have a big advantage when driving in heavy traffic.
Cons of automatic transmission cars
- Costly maintenance: A car with an automatic transmission requires much more maintenance than a manual car due to the complex nature of its gearbox. It also requires regular tune-ups and could have multiple issues to deal with.
- High initial cost: Again, the complex nature of the automatic gearbox means that such cars always have a higher base price compared to manual transmission cars.
Pros of manual transmission cars
- Better fuel consumption: Such cars are known to save owners around 5% to 15% on their fuel costs during their lifetimes.
- Inexpensive maintenance: The less complicated nature of the gearbox means that lesser number of repairs are needed for the same, thus lowering your car's maintenance costs overall.
- Increased control: While automatic cars choose the ideal gear for any situation on their own, manual cars hand that decision to you and allow you to gain more control when you anticipate various scenarios.
Cons of manual transmission cars
- Difficult to master: Learning to drive manual transmission cars is no menial task. The hand-eye coordination needed when hitting the clutch and shifting the stick in the right direction is difficult to come by in the first few attempts. So, someone who's driven a manual car will find it incredibly easy to drive an automatic one.
- Traffic woes: In heavy traffic, having to hit the clutch and shift gears regularly is absolutely frustrating. Manual cars must hence be avoided by people who find themselves in such situations often.
Now that you know all the pros and cons of automatic and manual transmission cars, you can make your own choice easily.
Great Deals on Used CarsView All Used Cars
- 77,000 km
- 47,549 km
- 62,246 km
- 65,210 km
- 70,457 km
- 24,000 km
- 54,000 km
- 44,112 km
- 14,500 km
- 66,823 km
3 hours ago
A strong push during the festive season helped Ola Electric achieve its highest-ever monthly sales, retaining its number-one position in the market.
4 hours ago
Gauhar Khan and her husband, Zaid Darbar, were pictured together at the dealership in Mumbai while taking delivery of their new Mercedes.
4 hours ago
Hero MotoCorp’s cumulative sales for November 2023 stood at 491,050 units, witnessing a 25.61 per cent increase year-on-year
5 hours ago
5 hours ago
The bikemaker’s cumulative motorcycle sales for the year 2023 stood at 621,672 units, reflecting a 13 per cent increase.
6 hours ago
In the previous month, the automaker sold a total of 11,891 units, marking a growth of 24 per cent as compared to the same month last year.
7 hours ago
At present, India’s largest carmaker holds just a little over 2.06 lakh open bookings, nearly a third of which are for the Ertiga.
8 hours ago
New variant of the Chetak scooter gets some changes as compared to the Premium variant currently on sale.
9 hours ago
The cumulative sales for the Calendar Year 2023 reached 2,10,497 units - a 40 per cent growth over 2022
9 hours ago
While sales were up in comparison to November 2022, Ather reported a 7 per cent decline in sales as compared to October 2023
1 year ago
The perennial debate that we wish to solve finally.
6 years ago
Bad traffic and ever lengthening commutes are pushing more and more consumers to buy pricier models that sport automatic gears and moving away from the manual stick-shifts that have long held sway over Indian roads.
9 years ago
Equipped with an Automated Manual Transmission (AMT), the Nano Twist F-Tronic could become the cheapest automatic car in the world, when it goes on sale.