logo
New Delhi

BMW X5 vs Mahindra Scorpio Comparison

Compare BMW X5 vs Mahindra Scorpio to know which is better. Detailed cars comparison on BMW X5 vs Mahindra Scorpio compare price, specs, mileage, performance, reviews and other features on car&bike.

X5 vs Scorpio Comparison Overview

Key HighlightsX5Scorpio
Price1 Cr3.33 L
Power2998 CC2179 CC
ClassSUVSUV
Mileage11 - 13 KM/L15 KM/L
X5
BMW X5
*Ex-Showroom Price
1 Cr
Scorpio
Mahindra Scorpio
*Ex-Showroom Price
3.33 L
+
Add
Only Show Differences
xDrive40i
BMW X5
xDrive40i
1 Cr
Xtreme
Mahindra Scorpio
Xtreme
3.33 L

Overview

Overall Rating
7.3
7.3
Value For Money7.508.00
Significance7.508.00
Styling7.506.75
Comfort8.757.25
Safety8.757.00
Environment-6.00
Merit Or Usp8.258.00

Specifications

Engine TypeTwinPower Turbo 6-cylinder Petrol EngineN/A
Displacement (CC)2998 CCN/A
No. of Cylinders6N/A
Power376 bhp@ 5200-6250 rpmN/A
Torque520 NmN/A
Top Speed243N/A
Acceleration 0 to 100 Kmph5.4N/A
No. of gears8N/A
Drive TrainAWDN/A
Turbocharger YesN/A
Emissions StandardBS6 Phase-2N/A

Features

Air Conditioner4-Zone Automatic Climate Control No
Front ACSingle Zone, Common Fan Speed Control No
Climate ControlFour Zone Automatic No
Cruise ControlAdaptive Cruise Control No
Adjustable Rear HeadrestsNA No

Pros Cons of BMW X5

Pros

  • Brilliantly sorted chassis
  • Punchy 3.0-litre inline-six engines
  • A split tailgate that makes loading heavy items simple

Cons

  • Overall, high maintenance costs
  • Top-spec trims get extremely expensive
  • The overreliance on touchscreen controls

Verdict

The BMW X5 remains one of the most thoroughly engineered luxury SUVs currently on the market. It manages to walk a very fine line between providing genuine family practicality and surprisingly sharp driving dynamics. The cabin is an incredibly comfortable place to spend time in, backed up by high-quality touchpoints and fantastic noise insulation.

While the heavy shift towards digital screens might alienate buyers who prefer physical dials, the tech works reliably once you get used to the menu layout. The engines offer superb grunt, whether you choose the frugal diesel or the rev-happy petrol. It doesn't quite have the outright interior space of a Mercedes-Benz GLE, nor the third-row practicality of an Audi Q7, but the X5 feels more engaging from the driver's seat. If you want a luxury family driver that actually rewards you when you push it hard, this is the one that deserves your money.

As Siddharth sums up the vehicle,

“Whether you are navigating congested city streets with its array of sensors or devouring highway miles, the X5 provides absolute peace of mind for both the driver and their family.”

Pros Cons of Mahindra Scorpio

Pros

  • Big on muscle and also legacy
  • The Scorpio gets a very refined diesel mHawk engine
  • The Scorpio is rugged and macho in terms of looks

Cons

  • The engine is a little noisy
  • The automatic transmission is a little sluggish
  • The Scorpio does not get many features

Verdict

The Mahindra Scorpio retains its iconic identity while presenting itself as more than just a familiar favorite in a revamped package. Considerable effort has been invested in its development, and the results are prominently visible. The vehicle exhibits significant enhancements over its predecessor, showcasing fine-tuning and improved overall performance. While there's always room for further aesthetic and driving experience enhancements, it's commendable that the Scorpio transcends beyond being a mere facelift. It genuinely represents a new generation, offering a fresh and evolved driving experience while staying true to the robust essence that has defined the Scorpio legacy.

Explore Cars Similar to BMW X5

Explore Cars Similar to Mahindra Scorpio

Popular New Car Comparison

Compare Cars By Body Type

Recent Popular Car Comparison In India

Read More on "BMW X5" vs "Mahindra Scorpio"