New Cars and Bikes in India

BMW X1 Vs Mercedes-Benz CLA Vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class comparison

  • BMW X1
BMW X1 Price
Mercedes-Benz CLA Price
Mercedes-Benz A-Class Price
Ex-Showroom Price
New Delhi
₹ 35.9 Lakh
Request Call Back
₹ 31.72 Lakh
Book Now
₹ 27.87 Lakh
Book Now

Overview

BMW X1 Vs Mercedes-Benz CLA Vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class Comparison: Which Car is Better?

Trying to figure out which of these cars to buy? Compare the X1 Vs CLA Vs A-Class on carandbike to make an informed buying decision as to which car to buy in 2020. This comparison has been carried out on the basis of prices, engine specifications, mileage, and features of these cars.

X1 Vs CLA Vs A-Class – Which model is Cheapest?

The ex-showroom, New Delhi price of the Petrol BMW X1 starts at ₹ 35.9 Lakh and goes up to ₹ 38.7 Lakh for the fully-loaded Petrol model. The base Diesel version of the BMW X1 costs ₹ 39.9 Lakh, whereas the BMW X1 Diesel top-end costs ₹ 42.9 Lakh. On the other hand, the price of the base Petrol version of the Mercedes-Benz A-Class starts at ₹ 27.87 Lakh. The base Diesel model of the Mercedes-Benz A-Class costs ₹ 29.26 Lakh Lastly, the Petrol Mercedes-Benz CLA starts at ₹ 35.99 Lakh. The base Diesel version of the Mercedes-Benz CLA costs ₹ 31.72 Lakh, whereas the Mercedes-Benz CLA Diesel top-end costs ₹ 36.99 Lakh.

Key FeaturesBMW X1Mercedes-Benz CLAMercedes-Benz A-Class
Price₹ 35.9 Lakh₹ 31.72 Lakh₹ 27.87 Lakh
Mileage14.82 Kmpl17.90 Kmpl15.50 Kmpl
Power192 bhp134 bhp122 bhp
Engine1998 CC2143 CC1595 CC
Fuel TypePetrolDieselPetrol

X1 Vs CLA Vs A-Class – Which gives Better Mileage?

As for the claimed fuel efficiency, the BMW X1 base Petrol engine returns 15 Kmpl, whereas the base diesel returns 20 Kmpl. The Mercedes-Benz A-Class base Petrol returns 16 Kmpl, whereas its base Diesel counterpart gives 20 Kmpl of fuel efficiency. The Mercedes-Benz CLA Petrol basic model, on the other hand, gives 15 Kmplwhile its Diesel base returns 18 Kmpl of mileage.

X1 Vs CLA Vs A-Class – Which has a Better Engine Efficiency?

In the powertrain department, the BMW X1 gets 192 bhp Petrol engine and 190 bhp Diesel engine, whereas the Mercedes-Benz A-Class comes in 122 bhp Petrol engine and 136 bhp Diesel engine. Lastly, the Mercedes-Benz CLA is offered in 181 bhp Petrol engine and 134 bhp Diesel engine.

Engine

Engine Type TwinPower Turbo 4-cylinder Engine4-Cylinder Diesel Engine Turbocharged4-cylinder In-line Engine. With Direct Petrol Injection, Variable Valve Timing And A Turbocharger
Displacement (CC) 1998 CC2143 CC1595 CC
No Of Cylinder 444
Power 192 bhp@5000-6000 rpm134 bhp@3600-4400 rpm122 bhp@5000 rpm
Torque 280 Nm@1350-4600 rpm300 Nm@1600-3000 rpm200 Nm@1250-4000 rpm
Drive Train FWDFWDFWD

Dimensions

Length 4447 mm4630 mm4299 mm
Width 2060 mm1777 mm1780 mm
Height 1612 mm1432 mm1433 mm
Wheelbase 2670 mm2699 mm2699 mm
Ground Clearance 175 mm160 mm160 mm
Boot Space 420 L470 L341 L
Kerb Weight 1470 Kg1570 Kg1395 Kg
Gross Weight 2000 Kg2005 Kg1920 Kg
Front Track 1561 mm1549 mm1553 mm
Rear Track 1562 mm1547 mm1522 mm
Minimum Turning Radius 5.80 m5.50 m5.50 m
No. Of Doors 545
Seating Capacity 555

Transmission

No. of gears AutomaticAutomaticAutomatic
Clutch Type N/ADual ClutchDual Clutch

Wheels & Tyres

Wheel Type Alloy WheelsAlloy WheelsMercedes-Benz Light-Alloy Wheels
Tyre Type Tubeless, RadialTubeless RadialTubeless Radial
Front Tyre Size 225/50 R18205/55 R 16205/55 R16
Rear Tyre Size 225/50 R18205/55 R 16205/55 R16

Braking System

Front Brake Type Ventilated DiscVentilated DiscVentilated Disc
Rear Brake Type DiscDiscDisc

Suspension

Front Suspension Double Joint Strut Sront AxleMcPherson StrutMcPherson Strut
Rear Suspension Double Joint Strut Sront AxleFour-link Four-link

Fuel Efficiency

Mileage City N/AN/A12.03 Kmpl
Mileage Highway N/AN/A15.00 Kmpl
Mileage 14.82 Kmpl17.90 Kmpl15.50 Kmpl
Fuel Tank Capacity 51.056.050.0

Steering

Power Steering
Steering Type Electric Power SteeringElectric Power SteeringElectric Power Steering
Adjustable Power Steering

Performance

Performance 0 To 100 Kmph 7.7 seconds9.8 seconds8.6 seconds
Max Speed 226220202

Safety & Security

Airbagstickticktick
Passenger Airbagstickticktick
Side Airbagstickticktick
ABStickticktick
Electronic Brakeforce Distributiontickticktick
Brake Assisttickticktick
Hill Assistcrossticktick
Electronic Stability Programtickticktick
Tractional Controltickticktick
Engine Immobilizertickticktick
Central Lockingtickticktick
Child Safety Locktickticktick
Power Door Locktickticktick
Automatic Headlampstickticktick
Cornering Lightstickcrosscross
Turn Indicators On ORVMtickticktick
Rear Wipertickcrosstick
Rain Sensing Wiperstickticktick
Headlight Washersticktickcross
Headlamp Beam Adjustertickticktick

Comfort & Convenience

Air ConditionerAutomatic - Dual ZoneAutomatic Climate ControlAutomatic Climate Control
Heatertickticktick
Steering AdjustmentTilt & TelescopicTilt & TelescopicTilt & Telescopic
Steering Mounted Audiotickticktick
Paddle Shiftticktickcross
Cruise Controltickticktick
Power Outlets 12Vtickticktick
Rear Parking Sensortickticktick
Rear Parking Cameratickticktick
Electrically Adjustable Rear View Mirrortickticktick
Push Start Stop Buttontickticktick
Height Adjustable Driver Seattickticktick
Lumbar Supporttickticktick
Front Armresttickticktick
Rear Armresttickticktick
UpholsteryLeatherARTICO LeatherARTICO/Messancy Fabric
Front Cup Holderstickticktick
Keyless Entrytickticktick
Climate Controltickticktick
One Touch Tumble Second Row Seatcross--
Shark Fin Antenna and Integrated Rear Spoilercross--

Lights

Light TypeLEDLEDLED
Front Fog Lampstickticktick
Rear Fog Lampstickticktick
Rear Unique Inverted Lightscross--

Instrumentation & Communication

Distance To Emptytickticktick
Average Fuel Efficiency Indicatortickticktick
Seat Belt Warningtickticktick
Low Fuel Warningtickticktick
Door Ajar Warningtickticktick
GPS Navigationtickticktick

Entertainment

Music Systemtickticktick
CD/DVD Playertickticktick
Speakerstickticktick
Internal Memorytickticktick
Radiotickticktick
USB Supporttickticktick
Bluetooth Supporttickticktick

Reviews

Expert Reviews
  • Review: Mercedes-Benz A Class

    Review: Mercedes-Benz A Class

    Sep 18, 2015 10:01 PM

    The Mercedes-Benz A-Class is a handsome looking car and it has a lot going for it in terms of looks. But how is it to drive or how practical is it in urban driving conditions? We drive it to find out. Read More

Also Read Expert Comparison Reviews of X1 and CLA and A-Class

Volvo XC40 vs BMW X1 vs Mercedes-Benz GLA vs Audi Q3: Comparison Review

Volvo XC40 vs BMW X1 vs Mercedes-Benz GLA vs Audi Q3: Comparison Review

By Cyrus Dhabhar 04-Jul-18

The Audi Q3 and the Mercedes-Benz GLA are both due for a replacement very soon as they are both quite deep into their life cycle. The Q3 in particular is getting quite irrelevant in this segment... Read More

Disclaimer: carandbike team has taken the utmost care to ensure the accuracy of the information provided above, however, we recommend that you contact the manufacturer or your nearest dealership to confirm the details. carandbike cannot be held liable for any direct or indirect damage/loss.
Mercedes Benz V Class Desktop